Margarita's Pizzeria

Nestled conveniently on West Beaver Avenue in the heart of State College, Margarita's Pizzeria is a standout destination for pizza lovers and casual diners alike. This cozy pizza restaurant has built a loyal local following thanks to its crave-worthy menu and warm, welcoming vibe that feels just right whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for a comforting meal.

Margarita’s menu offers an enticing range of Italian-American classics, with an emphasis on handcrafted pizzas that shine with vibrant flavors. The Personal Cheese Pizza is a guilty pleasure for many—a perfect balance of rich cheese melted over a perfectly crisp crust that earns enthusiastic praise. For those craving something a bit heartier, the Buffalo Chicken pizza bursts with a spicy kick, complemented by a tender, tangy sauce that dances across the palate.

The culinary creativity doesn’t stop at pizza. The Stromboli and Calzone options bring in robust fillings sealed inside golden, flaky dough, delivering comfort with every bite. Sandwich fans will appreciate the Fried Chicken Sandwich, paired with crispy fries—a satisfying combination that hits all the right notes. For lighter fare, the Chef’s Salad offers freshness and balance, while the 18 Cheese Pizza will satisfy the most devoted cheese aficionados with its decadent, multi-cheese melt.

What truly elevates Margarita’s experience not only lies in the food but also in the atmosphere and service. Many patrons highlight the friendly, personable nature of the owners who make every visit feel like catching up with friends. One customer shared how a simple trip to pick up a pizza turned into a warm and memorable conversation, reflecting the genuine community spirit that Margarita’s nurtures.

The flavors here are vivid and bold—the tangy tomato pesto, the melty mozzarella, the perfectly seasoned crust that Brown’s to a golden crisp. Tony Salinas, a recent Texan transplant, raves about the pizza being the best he’s ever tasted, giving top marks to the crust, sauce, and that delightful undercarriage crispiness that true pizza lovers cherish.

While some have noted the restaurant’s somewhat limited and enigmatic opening hours, most agree that the food alone is worth timing your visit accordingly. There is a $10 minimum for credit card purchases to keep in mind, but the generous portions and satisfying quality more than justify the trip.

Whether you’re a State College local or just passing through, Margarita’s Pizzeria offers a comforting and flavor-rich dining experience that leaves you coming back for more—even with leftovers to savor later. From their standout baked Italian subs to the classic favorites that have cemented their reputation, this pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic, mouthwatering pizza paired with real hometown charm.